Skip to main content

Best Pizza in Central Islip

Central Islip pizza since 1975.

Featured

View menu
Pizza, slices and pies

Pizza, slices and pies

The menu has pizza by the pie, slices, and specialty pies.
View menu
Buffalo chicken and garlic knots

Buffalo chicken and garlic knots

Get the buffalo chicken pizza and add a tray of garlic knots.

Current specials

Our specials change, so check the specials page before you order.
See specials

Find us on Wheeler Road

We've been in Central Islip since 1975. Pickup and delivery are available seven days a week.
Central Islip details

If you want to really thank your friends for helping you move shell out the money for the Central Pizza Taco pizza! I happened to find this place by accident and they had just made one for the lunch crowd. Every slice is a meal! There's so much toppings on it that you need a fork and knife for the first few bites. Some of the best crust I've tasted.

Andrew J.

One of the best pizzerias on Long Island hands down! Everything is amazing, in my opinion the best way to judge a pizzeria is their regular slice and trust me when I say this, they have one of the best regular slices I’ve ever had. Pizza is always on point never disappoints. Try the grandma slice too. If you’re in central islip this should be the only place you get pizza!

Deny E.

Central Pizza's pizza is unlike any other pizza iv had and my coworkers couldn't agree more! The vegetable pizza is so tasty with fresh vegetables and the garlic knots from this pizzeria are huge and soft like little buns! Everything about it is recommended 100%. Bring your friends and family down and enjoy

Office P.

Sal and the boys are the type of guys that make a stranger feel like they are family. The pizza is the best in the entire area. It is consistent everyday. Also, when you order a pasta dish, you get enough food to last you 3 days. You always get good service and good food every time. Try the Hawaiian slice. It is EXCELLENT!!!

Vito U.

excellent pizza! this is buffalo chicken my favorite one. the best pizzaria in the island and ezcellent service.

matheus S.

Central Pizza Rewards

Join our rewards program, earn points every time you order online and redeem your points for free food!
Join now

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular dishes?

Central Pizza is known for New York-style slices and classic pizzeria fare. Our most popular dishes include:

  • Large Cheese Pizza: Hand-tossed round pie with homemade tomato sauce and mozzarella, and any toppings added as desired.
  • Meatball Hero: Homemade meatballs in tomato sauce served on a hero roll.
  • Buffalo Wings: Twelve crispy chicken wings tossed in spicy buffalo sauce and served with blue cheese.
  • Buffalo Chicken Pizza: Spicy buffalo chicken and mozzarella sit on a white pie.
  • Pepperoni Slice: A classic New York slice topped with pepperoni, tomato sauce and mozzarella.
  • Spaghetti & Meatballs: Classic spaghetti and meatballs served in a homemade marinara sauce.

Check out our full menu.

What are you known for?

We’re known for Neapolitan and Sicilian pizza, hearty Italian pasta dishes, and parmigiana heroes, serving diners in Central Islip.

  • Italian Food: Italian favorites span pizza, baked pasta, parmigiana heroes, and chicken, veal, and seafood dishes. Examples include Neapolitan Pizza, Homemade Lasagna Pasta, Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana, Veal Marsala, Shrimp with Garlic & Oil, and Meatball Parmigiana Hero.
  • Pasta: Pasta dishes range from baked ziti and stuffed shells to creamy Alfredo, meat sauces, and red or white clam sauce. Examples include Baked Ziti Pasta, Stuffed Shells with Meatballs Pasta, Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken Pasta, Bolognese Pasta, and Clam Sauce (Red or White).
  • Pizza: Whole pies and slices cover Neapolitan, Sicilian, and Grandma styles alongside white pizza and chicken-topped specialties. Examples include Neapolitan Pizza, Sicilian Pizza, Grandma Pizza, White Pizza, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, and Pepperoni Slice.
  • Sandwiches: Hero sandwiches feature chicken cutlets, meatballs, sausage, shrimp, and egg fillings, with several parmigiana options. Examples include Chicken Cutlet Hero, Meatball Parmigiana Hero, Sausage & Peppers Hero, Shrimp Parmigiana Hero, and Potato & Eggs Hero.
  • Subs: From Buffalo chicken to sausage and peppers, these hero-style subs include meat, seafood, and vegetable-and-egg fillings. Examples include Buffalo Chicken Hero, Sausage & Peppers Hero, Veal Parmigiana Hero, Shrimp Parmigiana Hero, and Pepper & Eggs Hero.

Additionally, explore Chicken, Drinks, Seafood, Salads, and Hoagies.

What meals do you serve?

We serve Lunch and Dinner

Do you offer delivery & takeout?

Yes, we offer Delivery and Takeout

Do you offer catering?

Yes! Central Pizza offers catering for parties, office lunches, family gatherings, and other events.

Visit our catering page for more information.

What payment methods do you accept?

When you order online, we accept credit cards (Mastercard, Visa, American Express, Discover), Apple Pay, and Google Pay.

What areas do you serve?

We serve the following areas: Islip, Central Islip, Brentwood, East Brentwood, Hauppauge, Islandia, Smithtown, North Great River, Islip Terrace, North Bay Shore, Ronkonkoma, Pine Aire, Great River Station, East Hauppauge, Bohemia, Village of the Branch, Bay Shore, Nesconset, East Islip, and The Landing.

Our location

Map showing the location of Central Pizza on 32 Wheeler Rd C in Central Islip
Central Pizza

Central Islip, NY

Loading today's hours...
Order online
Order with AppOrder online